The narrator said, "Once the Police arrived at the docks, they saw that both The Slaying Mask and the werewolf were gone, and a troop of vampires closed in on Megan and Angelica, who got stuck in a fish pile." Franco returned as himself instead of The Slaying Mask, bringing Joseph with him. Megan said, "Joseph?" Megan saw Joseph wearing his amulet, and the full moon was out, but he wasn't a werewolf. Franco and Joseph then went over to Megan and Angelica and helped them out of the pile of fish. After they did, the vampires surrounded Angelica, Franco, Joseph, and Megan and started to walk toward them while the Police watched. Matthew said, "Hand over the werewolf, or you're all bloodless vampires." Angelica said, "Except me. I'm already a vampire." Matt said, "Don't worry. I thought of you." Matt brought out a wooden stake, and the other vampires hid from it. Matt said, "One false move and I stake you."
Angelica, Joseph, Megan, and Franco all put their hands in the air so the vampires or policepeople wouldn't stake or shoot them. Megan said, "Well, I hope you're happy, Angelica." Angelicia said, "Me? I don't see how this is my fault. Who lured my ex-friends here in the first place?" Megan felt Angelica was talking about her and said, "Franco was the one who lured the police here." Franco said, "Joseph turned himself into a werewolf." Megan said, "And refused to give up the power." Joseph said, "I still liked Angelica." Angelica said, "Well, that wouldn't have happened if Matt didn't resurrect me or if you had broken up with me instead of me breaking up with you." Joseph said, "It's not my fault he wanted you and his crew back, and I'm still in love with you. So you broke my heart. I bet if I broke up with you, you would be heartbroken, because you do have a heart, but you're already dead, so what harm could it have done?" Megan said, "Maybe if we just turned your friends in, as I said we should do, none of this would have happened, and we wouldn't be in this predicament."
Chief Jade then blew an air horn to stop them from arguing and shouted through a bullhorn. Chief Jade said into her bullhorn, "Monsters of Transylvania! Leave the citizens of Transylvania alone and surrender yourselves! No harm will come to you! We'll only handcuff you and take you to a nice, dark jail where you can't harm anyone, and nobody can harm you! And don't get any ideas, because we see you and have you surrounded." The vampires and Megan looked around and saw they were surrounded by police officers holding guns and wooden stakes up to them. Karly said, "One move and you're all more dead than you already are." Joseph said, "Fine. If you let us go, you can take the vampires, because we're the ones they want to kill."
Chief Jade then handcuffed Matthew and Raven while her police squad handcuffed the other vampires, except for Angelica. Chief Jade said, "Ok, now that we have you, hand over the mayor's trophy." Megan said, "We stole it back and got it back in the car." Megan took Chief Jade to her car and returned the trophy to her. Once they retrieved it, Chief Jade took a close look at the trophy. Chief Jade said, "Wait a second. This isn't the mayor's trophy." Chief Jade took the top off and showed everyone the wire. Chief Jade said, "It's a blender." Megan, Joseph, Franco, the police, and the vampires all got confused and said, "Huh," simultaneously. Angelica then laughed evilly, as if she knew. Everyone around her got shocked and simultaneously said, "What?"
The narrator said, "Angelica then explained how she had pulled off her heist and tricked everyone by making them recall what had previously happened." Angelica grabbed a bomb from The Slaying Mask's lair while she was gathering her gear, and she secretly stole their blender before they went to commit their trophy heist. They also recalled that before Angelica dumped Joseph, she told Megan what everyone does, including her. And since she's the best at hypnosis, she got an idea when they were captured with The Slaying Mask by the vampires after falling for their trap. So, when Matt took the trophy back, she hypnotized the rats on the floor to work together to steal the trophy and replace it with the blender she had stolen from their kitchen. Then Matt locked the blender up while the rats put the trophy and the bomb with their stolen loot. While Angelica, The Slaying Mask, Megan, and Joseph were stealing the blender, Chris walked in with Carolyn, and they spotted all four of them stealing the blender, thinking it was the trophy, and stuffing it into Angelica's bag. Angelica said, "Don't mind us. We're just robbing this trophy." Angelica then shot a line from her watch and swung across the room on it. Once she was re-joined with Megan, Joseph, and The Slaying Mask, they all made a run for it. Then Chris and Carolyn ran after them because they wanted the mayor's trophy back. Then Megan gave the police the blender, thinking it was the trophy.
Matt pointed at the blender and said, "If that's a blender, then where's the...?" Angelica laughed and said, "The old switcheroo." Angelica checked her watch and figured it was about time for her plan to be put into action. She snapped her fingers and pointed at the castle, even though it was far away and they couldn't see it. Then they saw a giant smoke screen fire high in the sky from far away, and all their stolen loot fell from the sky. Carolyn said, "Angelica gave away all our loot. We stole it fair and square." Chief Jade said, "It's not all present. Where's the mayor's trophy?" Chief Jade looked up and saw the trophy fall from the sky and land right in front of her. Angelica then waved goodbye to Matt, because she was done there. The Police then loaded the evil vampires into their police van and shut the door. Angelica said, "Oh, and when the sun rises and you get fried, it may sting a little." Angelica then laughed while she walked away.